personally I refuse to vote for goalies in polls like this. They should be their own category.Bourque over Roy is just crazy
Thats fair. An all time great goalie's impact on winning is going to be immeasurably higher than most people on the ice just on the basis they are out there all 60.personally I refuse to vote for goalies in polls like this. They should be their own category.
who's better, Sidney Crosby or Vesa Toskala?personally I refuse to vote for goalies in polls like this. They should be their own category.
So is it Cups or Conn Smythe's? Make up your mindRecency and regular season bias.
I like players with multiple Conn Smythe’s the best. If I can have five all time greats, of course my goal is to win the Stanley Cup.
So is it Cups or Conn Smythe's? Make up your mind
With an all time name like Vesa? That'll get locked quickwho's better, Sidney Crosby or Vesa Toskala?
Lidstrom over Bourque is what I find crazy.Bourque over Roy is just crazy
me too!Crosby
Jagr
Hasek
Ovie
Bourque
After roy yes.The first 5 players.
@tarheelhockey 100% agreed. I was gonna post that. Including Orr, Potvin is one of the top four post-O6 dmen of all time.Potvin is being seriously disrespected in this poll. The question is “best player” not “longest career”. Potvin at his peak has an argument to be a top-3 player on this list.