I've been using
hockeystatcards game score composition metric to rate each of the defensemen as the season progresses.
View attachment 761675
Couple things that stand out (all metric based thoughts - clearly adv. stats don't tell a complete story)
- Toews... WTF man. Manson and JJ have put up better advanced stats on a nightly basis than you
- Byram had a rough first four games, but has consistently been their best defenseman since then
- Girard is a tale of two different players, he jumps back and forth quite a bit
- I still don't think Makar is 100% healthy, which is probably impacting Toews (as I believe Toews' success at least somewhat depends on Makar carrying that pairing)