ACC1224
Super Elite, Passing ALL Tests since 2002
- Aug 19, 2002
- 74,368
- 40,284
Could be that he isn't ready to commit yet. I'm guessing something will happen within the next week.
Player Discussion Marner
- Thread starter ACC1224
- Start date
MCR74
Registered User
- Nov 11, 2022
- 3,253
- 3,563
ULF_55
Moderator
Or the other Pat to give them a hug. Bear hug ...
Of course prime aged Mark Messier in the room would work ...
3blizzard4
Registered User
Tak7
Registered User
Nor should he be ready - seems like he's the big domino that everyone else is waiting for fall. He's probably never going to have this sort of interest / leverage again in his life, so fair play to him for trying to stretch it out and maximize his perceived worth currently (which I personally think is nuts).
Mess
Global Moderator
In fairness Marner has a past history of rebelling against strong management,
He didn't like when Lou Lam didn't give him all his rookie bonus in his ELC as Mitch believed he was entitled to. Complained publicly and then made Clueless Dubass on his next deal to make him right,
Marner certainly didn't like Mike Babcock style of coaching and motivation as he didn't get his way to play with Matthews, and didn't like the coach shared other info that Marner had provided the coach.
Remember Babcock buried Marner down the Leafs line-up trying to keep him away from tougher match-ups and a balanced Top 9 not top heavy Top 6.
Hyman --- Matthews -- Nylander
Marleau -- Kadri ------- Brown
JVR ------- Bozak ----- Marner
People forget one of Marner MOST productive playoff seasons came when Mike Babcock was his coach and they took Boston to 7 games in 2017-18. Where he had 2-7-9 points and +2 ..
The Iceman
Registered User
- Sep 22, 2007
- 5,115
- 3,774
Could Rod B be available if Carolina loses?
How about Lavy if NYR blow a 3-0 lead.
Burns or Quinn.
No coincidence this was the last two successful Leaf coaches built around top goalies and gritty teams.
- Sep 8, 2004
- 15,161
- 1,825
whenever they put 'realistic' in the title, it never is.
they are mostly bad, and seriously, taking Kerfoot back in a Marner deal. (Kerfoot the Utah #5 rated prospect and a 2nd) realistically BAD
ACC1224
Super Elite, Passing ALL Tests since 2002
- Aug 19, 2002
- 74,368
- 40,284
He played years under Hunter and excelled. No one likes to play for an idiot like Babcock.
Darcy Tucker
My Name is Bob
Wow these people are wacked in the head. The only way I'm dealing Marner is if we get a similar level player back and we don't have to retain. 1 for 1 to NJ for Timo Meier or something to that effect. The Dman we should get back for Marner other teams won't let go so that seems like a pipe dream. Give me another offensive talent and not magic beans and then I'm open to it. Marner is 27 and is a guaranteed 90+ point player. We need to stop the hysteria around him.
notDatsyuk
Registered User
- Jul 20, 2018
- 10,117
- 8,105
A lot of whining about the powerless play, but nothing constructive.
I didn't hear anything about tougher matchups. Maybe the fact that Mitch plays with Matty and Willy plays with JT has more to do with the 'tougher matchups' than his personal performance. Watching the playoffs, the two players Boston was keying on were Matty and Willy (except on the PK where they keyed on JT because he was the easy one to get the puck off).
Tak7
Registered User
It's been quite a while since, but did he really complain publicly? I can't remember, and couldn't find anything suggesting he did - I thought the disagreement about bonuses only came out when Dreger was on the Darren Ferris Campaign Tour for the next deal
I wouldn't underestimate a Mitch Marner on the open market. Its a dynamic situation and there will be a lot of gamesmanship at play. Leafs are in a tough spot no doubt but they may have more leverage than it seems. Could go a lot of different ways.
Egghead1999
Registered User
- Nov 9, 2007
- 3,226
- 897
The Panthers did not turn into SCC and PT winners instantly after they got Tkachuk. You miss a couple of details.The Florida Panthers were "Pretenders" until they traded their soft but highly skilled forward Huberdeau that was coming off a season where he finished 2nd in scoring behind only McDavid.
View attachment 871547
Some people forget this,
Then they got a real playoff hockey player in Tkachuk and suddenly the Panthers have become "Contenders" and President trophy winners so not just regular season ONLY but also playoffs.
- The Panthers almost missed the playoff last year (you forget their turnaround game that was against the Leafs, their HC was yelling at them at the bench after 1-3?? in the first 15 minutes?? and Tkachuk's dad just called the whole Panthers team soft a few days earlier)
- The Panthers were also 1-3 vs Boston in the 1st round last playoff
You are right though, after Huberdeau was gone and Tkachuk was here, somehow, Sam Reinhart and Sam Bennett started to play like a "bigger" player. Tre must believe he is on a Groundhog Day. He is back to deal with the same shxx again
Punch Drunk Loov
Thought Viktor Loov was going to be a guy
- Dec 6, 2011
- 5,171
- 3,161
Mitch throwing his gloves mid-game because he's worried about what the newspaper will print is one of the dumber takes I've heard
ACC1224
Super Elite, Passing ALL Tests since 2002
- Aug 19, 2002
- 74,368
- 40,284
Agree there, he was just frustrated, cares too much sometimes.
Leafs are keeping Matty and Willy and i am glad this assessment had been made .. they are our best 2 players who have well rounded skill sets (although I do worry both take too many games off) .. my guess is Woll is off da table too .. and i hope Benoit and McCabe are too .. those are da 5 guys who you build retooled team around if it was me .. add in Cowan, Holmberg, Knies and McMann .. then everyone else you look to trade to get better with .. for me I would resign Domi and Bert if possible .. and unless JT helps out on LTIR he will be on 3rd line .. but biggest changes required on this team are getting a bigger faster stronger D corps .. hopefully Rielly and Mitch can help get that accomplished .. there is a chance Tre can retool this summer and build us a better playoff type team
thewave
Registered User
- Jun 17, 2011
- 40,812
- 10,929
This is what happens when you give the kids the keys.
Who needs a motivated highly determined commander of a man like Gary Roberts when you can have a guy that throws his gloves and cries in a penalty box.
Gary Nylund
Registered User
- Oct 10, 2013
- 30,284
- 23,025
The whole Oates segment was hilarious. From the botox to everything that came out of his mouth, comedy gold.
MCR74
Registered User
- Nov 11, 2022
- 3,253
- 3,563
Gary would beat his ass if he was on the team. It would be a welcome change.
thewave
Registered User
- Jun 17, 2011
- 40,812
- 10,929
Back in the day. I could see Mitch getting popped one by a teammate
It's a tough example to use because the 120 point piece fell off a cliff, but at the time, the Flames got a staggering return for Tkachuk dollar for dollar, given the similar circumstances.
I wouldn't expect any of the players we might receive to get cut in half on their way here.
Evilhomer
Registered User
- Oct 10, 2019
- 3,993
- 3,824
? Bennett has always played exactly how he is playing now. He certainly didn't need Tkachuk to make him play "bigger". Sam Reinhart's offensive production also has virtually nothing to do with Tkachuk (except maybe in relation to power play points, I guess). Reinhart's increase in production very nicely correlates with when he started playing with Barkov (Reinhart With Barkov Stats | StatMuse). To be honest, I'm pretty sure if you look at any player's stats with and without Barkov there will likely be a material difference. He makes everyone around him better.
Lost me when he proposed bringing Kerfoot back
Trapper
Registered User
- Nov 21, 2013
- 24,278
- 12,111
I’ll take Theodore and Hill from Vegas instead of the 1st thanks.
