Player Discussion Joshua Roy

[Lafleurs Guy]

Kessel was borderline elite. Let's just say he was certainly better than Kyrou.

About half of those players are (give or take) as good or better as Kyrou though and that's my point. I'd say If you have around 50% chances to get someone as good as Kyrou and around 10-15% chances to get an elite player then i'll try my luck.

I think people who think (there's many on this board) that we are just one Kyrou away from winning are as delusional as Dorion was when he tried to win last summer. We need prime elite skills and Kyrou is not elite skills. Unless you can get clear as day elite skills (mid 20ies) for a package made of dunno Mailloux and the 5th then i'm personally not doing it.

That 5th is our best trade asset. I can't begin to understand why anyone would trade our best asset for Kyrou. It's like when Atkins traded Moreno for Vasrho. He had to get a top of the line hitter and his best asset was Moreno. He traded his best asset for a guy who while good was not good enough. That 5th is not moving unless the return is a solid clear as day ppg+ player in his mid 20ies.

At 1st you’ve got great odds of getting a superstar. At five, you got great odds of getting a really good player and an outside shot at a superstar.

Kessel was a borderline superstar. Top ten scorer in the 2010s. If he didn’t play in that low scoring era he’d probably go to the HOF.

I wouldn’t give up the 5th for Kyrou.

 

[Mrb1p]

And yet some people want Keller with the same shitty stats... As a winger no less.

Keller is much better than Kyrou and Kyrou hasn't played a shift at center in the NHL. He's a winger. He played a few shifts in Sarnia at C early on and was drafted as a C in the OHL.

 

[vokiel]

Keller is much better than Kyrou and Kyrou hasn't played a shift at center in the NHL. He's a winger. He played a few shifts in Sarnia at C early on and was drafted as a C in the OHL.

Advanced stats disagree: Jordan Kyrou - Fantasy Hockey Game Logs, Advanced Stats and more - Frozen Tools

Kyrou has played center for a good part of the season, although I do remember watching some Blues games where he was on the wing, yes.

 

[Captain Mountain]

Advanced stats disagree: Jordan Kyrou - Fantasy Hockey Game Logs, Advanced Stats and more - Frozen Tools

Kyrou has played center for a good part of the season, although I do remember watching some Blues games where he was on the wing, yes.

That's not advanced stats. Nor does it say he's playing center. Its scraped from data NHL makes available and isn't a reflection of the position players play on a line/pair. I'm actually pretty sure its reflection of whose number comes first (left to right). I will bet you anything that Kyrou was not the one centering Robert Thomas. For instance, here's Suzuki's:

Nick Suzuki - Fantasy Hockey Game Logs, Advanced Stats and more - Frozen Tools

Find out Nick Suzuki's latest linemates, game logs, advanced stats, player cards, news and analysis from dobberhockey.com

frozenpool.dobbersports.com

Suzuki is not listed in the middle in any line combination, but we've got:

NICK SUZUKI - ALEX NEWHOOK - JOSH ANDERSON
NICK SUZUKI - COLE CAUFIELD - JOSH ANDERSON
NICK SUZUKI - JURAJ SLAFKOVSKY - COLE CAUFIELD
NICK SUZUKI - ALEX NEWHOOK - BRENDAN GALLAGHER
etc.

Kyrou has taken 61 faceoffs in his NHL career total. That's regular season and playoffs combined (355 games). He is not a center.

 

[vokiel]

That's not advanced stats. Nor does it say he's playing center. Its scraped from data NHL makes available and isn't a reflection of the position players play on a line/pair. I'm actually pretty sure its reflection of whose number comes first (left to right). I will bet you anything that Kyrou was not the one centering Robert Thomas. For instance, here's Suzuki's:

Nick Suzuki - Fantasy Hockey Game Logs, Advanced Stats and more - Frozen Tools

Find out Nick Suzuki's latest linemates, game logs, advanced stats, player cards, news and analysis from dobberhockey.com

frozenpool.dobbersports.com

Suzuki is not listed in the middle in any line combination, but we've got:

NICK SUZUKI - ALEX NEWHOOK - JOSH ANDERSON
NICK SUZUKI - COLE CAUFIELD - JOSH ANDERSON
NICK SUZUKI - JURAJ SLAFKOVSKY - COLE CAUFIELD
NICK SUZUKI - ALEX NEWHOOK - BRENDAN GALLAGHER
etc.

Kyrou has taken 61 faceoffs in his NHL career total. That's regular season and playoffs combined (355 games). He is not a center.

Hmm good point

 

[Mrb1p]

Advanced stats disagree: Jordan Kyrou - Fantasy Hockey Game Logs, Advanced Stats and more - Frozen Tools

Kyrou has played center for a good part of the season, although I do remember watching some Blues games where he was on the wing, yes.

No he has not.

 

[Vachon23]

I thought I was in the Joshua Roy thread

 

[Lafleurs Guy]

I thought I was in the Joshua Roy thread

In the spirit of getting things back on track, I’m curious to see where he winds up next year in terms of lines. If they keep the first line together then I suspect we’ll see Roy with Dach and Newhook.

Otherwise it wouldn’t surprise me to see him with Dach and Caufield. That’d give us two solid lines and I don’t think CC and Newhook on the same line makes sense.

Either way, I’m hoping Roy can make a Calder run.

 

[Vachon23]

In the spirit of getting things back on track, I’m curious to see where he winds up next year in terms of lines. If they keep the first line together then I suspect we’ll see Roy with Dach and Newhook.

Otherwise it wouldn’t surprise me to see him with Dach and Caufield. That’d give us two solid lines and I don’t think CC and Newhook on the same line makes sense.

Either way, I’m hoping Roy can make a Calder run.

Depends who they acquired during the offseason, I hope he got a shot on the top 6

 

[Tyson]

In the spirit of getting things back on track, I’m curious to see where he winds up next year in terms of lines. If they keep the first line together then I suspect we’ll see Roy with Dach and Newhook.

Otherwise it wouldn’t surprise me to see him with Dach and Caufield. That’d give us two solid lines and I don’t think CC and Newhook on the same line makes sense.

Either way, I’m hoping Roy can make a Calder run.

Believe it or not but Logan Stankoven only played 24 games for Dallas this year and will be eligible for the Calder next season. 24 games and a long play off run and is still considered a rookie next season.

 

[KevSkillz4]

I stay with my comparable Tyler Toffoli for Joshua Roy. I think he will be a very good top 6 player, but can easily become a really good top 9 on a contender team.

 

[Lafleurs Guy]

Depends who they acquired during the offseason, I hope he got a shot on the top 6

I'd have him in the top six regardless. Newhook can move to the third.

 

[Scintillating10]

If we don't acquire anybody Roy will be given good opportunity

 

[Scriptor]

If we don't acquire anybody Roy will be given good opportunity

If we acquire an NHL-ready, top-6 forward, maybe Newhook deserves a shot at being the other one, to be fair, but I'd test Roy there as as well, at least.

A Cup-contending Hab roster upfront would look like this to me, in the end:

Caufield - Suzuki - Slafkovsky
Drafted top-6 - Dach - Trade-acquired top-6
UFA - Newhook- Roy
XXX -Beck - XXX

 

[windycity]

At the end of the day, he's able to watch much more than I am, and his evaluations will be much more accurate.

I'll support the moves he makes, and only really judge them a few years down the line.

I actually think it's unfair to judge a trade after the fact when you have the benefit of hindsight. It should be judged at the time imo, it's easy to judge after. Like the Lehky deal looked fine at the time but not so good now.

 

[Habs Halifax]

At 1st you’ve got great odds of getting a superstar. At five, you got great odds of getting a really good player and an outside shot at a superstar.

Kessel was a borderline superstar. Top ten scorer in the 2010s. If he didn’t play in that low scoring era he’d probably go to the HOF.

I wouldn’t give up the 5th for Kyrou.

Yup. I like Kyrou's game but no way I'm trading the 5th pick for Kyrou. I would consider Guhle+ for Kyrou though.

 

[Habs Halifax]

I actually think it's unfair to judge a trade after the fact when you have the benefit of hindsight. It should be judged at the time imo, it's easy to judge after. Like the Lehky deal looked fine at the time but not so good now.

I was one of the ones defending Lehkonen's value. Said it time and time again, he was a victim of being bounced around our line-up with poor center depth.

Still time left with Barron. Lets remember that Lehkonen took off at what age? If Barron can figure out the maturity/trust part in the D zone, he's going to be a top 4RD.

Lots of fans loosing patience with Barron to quickly. They may be right that he takes forever to figure it out (like Beaulieu) but he could turn into a Matheson if he does.

Plus we have not selected our player with the Avs 2nd yet. Should be around 55-60 which is a decent dart.

 

[Canadiens98]

I actually think it's unfair to judge a trade after the fact when you have the benefit of hindsight. It should be judged at the time imo, it's easy to judge after. Like the Lehky deal looked fine at the time but not so good now.

I see your point, but judging a trade before seeing what the incoming player can do for you seems harsh as well.

 

[CanadienShark]

I thought I was in the Joshua Roy thread

I vote we rename this thread!