Rate my NFL fantasy league trade

I gave:Ahman Green,Marvin Harrison and Chad Pennington

I received: Jamal Lewis,Randy Moss and Steve Mcnair

I'd say you did. Lewis is coming off a record season, and McNair was just co-MVP. While Harrison is better than Moss, the difference is not much. I look at it like this:

Moss<Harrison
Lewis<<Green
McNair>>>Pennington

I definetly think you did.

Lewis is the Ravens offense.
McNair is better than Pennington.
Moss has the big play ability and will score more TDs.

I gave:Ahman Green,Marvin Harrison and Chad Pennington

I received: Jamal Lewis,Randy Moss and Steve Mcnair

Moss and Harrison are a wash. When healthy, Moss is the best, hands down. Moss has had a foot problem. That said, he had it since week 5 last year and it didn't stop him from leading the league in TDs and notching 1600+ yards. Harrison is in a contract year, so has high incentive to excel.

Green>Lewis, but not by much. The biggest difference is the TD gap. However, Packers will turn to Davenport more in the red zone in order to keep Green fresh. Lewis IS the Ravens offense, while 2000 yards are a tough act to follow, I think he is a lock for 1500.

McNair and Pennington are equals IMO. Fantasy-football wise anyway.

In all, I think the winner of the trade will be determined by health. If McNair and Moss are 100%, you win.

I think he won it.