Trade Proposal from Boston

Brad Boyes, Nick Boynton, and Milan Jurcina

for

Vitali Vishnevski, Ruslan Salei, and Andy MacDonald

???

maybe take out Jurcina and MacDonald?

Sub Gill for Boynton?

thoughts?

No

I don't like that deal, to me Vish must remain and I would like to see Salei forever with a Ducks jersey.

Brad Boyes, Nick Boynton, and Milan Jurcina

for

Vitali Vishnevski, Ruslan Salei, and Andy MacDonald

???

maybe take out Jurcina and MacDonald?

Sub Gill for Boynton?

thoughts?

The Ducks need a first-line center. I don't see how this deal would help us.

Brad Boyes, Nick Boynton, and Milan Jurcina

for

Vitali Vishnevski, Ruslan Salei, and Andy MacDonald

???

maybe take out Jurcina and MacDonald?

Sub Gill for Boynton?

thoughts?

Everyone wants Vishnevski right now. He is a good young d-man who is about to become a reliable top 4 guy. I don't think the Ducks would move him.

McDonald and Vish probably aren't going anywhere because they don't make a lot of money and they have each played pretty well so far. Salei on the other hand is on the trade block as he is a UFA this summer.

I could see Salei for Boyes and a pick at the trade deadline if Boston is a playoff team and the Ducks are not.

Brad Boyes, Nick Boynton, and Milan Jurcina

for

Vitali Vishnevski, Ruslan Salei, and Andy MacDonald

???

maybe take out Jurcina and MacDonald?

Sub Gill for Boynton?

thoughts?

Nick Boynton= Difficult Negotiations, if he was difficult in BOS, he'd be worse in Anaheim

Milan Jurcina= 8th Round 2001 draft pick? good size but cmon does he really belong in the new NHL? looks like a pylon to me.


Brad Boyes= The only decent thing you threw out there. But if your thinking is esentially vish for boyes, Boyes has a LOOOOOONG way to go to get on Vish's level.


Vishnevski= Future of the Ducks Defensive core.

Salei= Great to good dman. BB says he plays the style he likes. But his lack of a contract (next season) may seem him go. Hes not overpaid so i cant see burke just giving him to anyone.

McDonald= One of (if not the) fastest ducks this season. give up more if you want a player who is doing great with the new rules.

call me a homer if you want, but the level of talent your offering for what you would be getting is silly.

McDonald really isn't doing all that much better than in the old system. The proposal still doesn't help us, though.

Nick Boynton= Difficult Negotiations, if he was difficult in BOS, he'd be worse in Anaheim

Milan Jurcina= 8th Round 2001 draft pick? good size but cmon does he really belong in the new NHL? looks like a pylon to me.


Brad Boyes= The only decent thing you threw out there. But if your thinking is esentially vish for boyes, Boyes has a LOOOOOONG way to go to get on Vish's level.


Vishnevski= Future of the Ducks Defensive core.

Salei= Great to good dman. BB says he plays the style he likes. But his lack of a contract (next season) may seem him go. Hes not overpaid so i cant see burke just giving him to anyone.

McDonald= One of (if not the) fastest ducks this season. give up more if you want a player who is doing great with the new rules.

call me a homer if you want, but the level of talent your offering for what you would be getting is silly.

You're a "homer". That said, you're also 100% correct.