Legwand or Arnott?

For a standard one-year Yahoo league, which player would you rather have? Legwand obviously has a higher upside, but is he likely to reach it?

What kind of numbers would you expect from the two?

I'm guessing Arnott at 45-50 and Legwand maybe in the low to mid 50's. But his +/- will be worse.

I would take Jason Arnott.

I would take Jason Arnott.

When in doubt, always take the player on the better team. You will get better +/- that way. Arnott it is.

When in doubt, always take the player on the better team. You will get better +/- that way. Arnott it is.

Arnott well play on the wing this year with Modano and Guerin...remember what he did with Elias and Sykora...